KITCHEN MAKEOVER

How I Elevated Our Basic Builder Peninsula Into a Cozy Showstopper

Shiplap, SW Urbane Bronze, and a Vacuum Cleaner Accident That Started It All

October 2025 6 min read
BEFORE

Basic Builder Peninsula

Before photo of basic builder-grade kitchen peninsula with plain drywall back

Functional, sure. But it wasn't giving the warm-hug, cozy-core energy our home deserves. Plain drywall, basic trim, and zero personality.

If there's one thing I've learned after remodeling our kitchen, it's that sometimes the simplest upgrades make the biggest impact. Our peninsula was one of those basic add-ons that came with the remodel — functional, sure, but it didn't give me that warm-hug, cozy-core energy I want every corner of our home to have.

And then there was the day my vacuum cleaner decided to declare war.

More on that in a moment.

The Accident That Forced My Hand… Thanks, Vacuum

Picture this: I'm vacuuming like a responsible adult, and the vacuum clips the corner of the peninsula. Hard. The corner trim snapped clean off and left a chunk missing.

So that suddenly became a problem.

When I pulled the old trim off to replace it, I realized the situation was even worse — the trim took half the side of the cabinets with it. The exposed MDF was rough, splintered, and definitely not giving "elevated cozycore." It was giving "DIY emergency room."

Damaged corner of kitchen peninsula after trim removal showing exposed MDF

If I was going to fix the corner, I might as well upgrade the whole thing, right?

Right.

Step 1: Adding Shiplap to the Back Panel

The back of the peninsula started as plain drywall — fine, functional, but not special. With the trim disaster giving me no choice but to rethink things, I decided to add vertical shiplap paneling across the entire back and wrap it into the corner.

Instant transformation.

The lines added warmth and quiet texture, and suddenly the peninsula felt like an intentional furniture piece instead of an afterthought from the remodel.

Vertical shiplap paneling installed on kitchen peninsula back panel

Step 2: Painting It Sherwin-Williams Urbane Bronze

You know I love a moody moment. And if I'm painting something anyway because of vacuum-induced chaos? I'm going bold.

SW Urbane Bronze grounded the entire kitchen, tied in the floors, and added that elevated modern-cozy vibe I'm always chasing. It's luxe without being loud. Cozy without being dark. Exactly what our kitchen needed.

Kitchen peninsula painted in Sherwin-Williams Urbane Bronze

Step 3: Adding Knobs for a Fully Custom Furniture Look

To finish it off, I added knobs to the peninsula panels. It seems small, but this is the detail that makes the entire piece look custom — like it was built as a standalone furniture unit, not attached as an afterthought.

These little touches are what make a home feel layered and lived-in without feeling cluttered.

Step 4: Replacing the Trim the Vacuum Tried to End

With the shiplap installed and the paint cured, I added new trim to the edges — thicker, more intentional, and infinitely sturdier than what was there before.

I'm happy to report: the peninsula is now vacuum-proof. (Probably.)

AFTER

Elevated Cozy Showstopper

Finished kitchen peninsula with shiplap, Sherwin-Williams Urbane Bronze paint, and custom hardware

From basic builder-grade to intentional, elevated, and cozy. The shiplap adds texture, the Urbane Bronze brings warmth, and the custom hardware makes it look like a high-end furniture piece. Mission accomplished. ✨

Watch the Final Reveal

See the finished peninsula in all its cozy glory!

Why This "Small" Project Made Such a Big Impact

The peninsula sits right in the daily traffic path. We see it constantly. Before, it blended in. After the makeover — and the unplanned trim incident — it now grounds the kitchen, adds warmth, and brings the entire remodel together.

The best part? This whole project was simple. Thoughtful. Impactful. The kind of upgrade that makes your home feel cozier the second you see it.

Thinking About Updating Your Peninsula?

If you're dealing with boring builder basics… or a vacuum-assisted demolition moment… this is your sign.

A little shiplap

A deep cozy paint color

Fresh trim

A few knobs

...can completely transform a space.

Stick around — this kitchen remodel has been full of "happy accidents" and cozy upgrades, and I'm sharing every one.

Love Cozy Kitchen Transformations?

Subscribe for more budget-friendly makeovers and DIY design ideas!

Subscribe Now